You know there is a nursing shortage right now. No-one wants to pay nurses what they’re worth and nurses are leaving the profession in droves. Some cite the crazy hours that ruin marriages and turn family life into a desperate relay race with childcare providers. Some cite miserable treatment by doctors and other hospital staff. Others cite the overwhelming and heartbreaking needs of patients in understaffed hospitals. I do know this: a nurse with an AA makes sometimes twice as much as a school teacher in the same neighborhood and it’s not enough to keep these people on the job.
We’re losing teachers left and right for the same reason: the money is not worth the constant personal humiliation, the exasperation of the work, the workload, the unruly children whose lives teachers are daily expected to transform despite daunting socioeconomic conditions and abusive parents and the exhaustion attendant with trying to change the world when you can’t even afford a decent lunch. Yes, but (many non-teachers say), the pay is for a “shortened” work day and summers “off,” but people don’t realize the extra hours of grading and course planning off the clock that will many times extend a work day into the double digits. As to the couple of months off, despite the fact that most teachers teach summers, any job that regularly required ten-hour days would normally either allow for substantial breaks in between projects or simply pay better. As it is, our nation’s teachers are voting with their feet – they’re taking their talents elsewhere. I know three school teachers in my immediate social group. They are each leaving their jobs for other schools, other countries or other professions entirely. And I won’t even touch the position of the local professoriate whose pay is commensurate with a well-trained legal secretary, but who are supposed to write a book every three years and teach 4-5 classes each semester, whose students disdain homework, whose buildings run with roaches and sewage, whose few superstars set public perception of pay and perks (like assuming all musicians are wealthy because Mick Jagger has amassed millions) but whose administration measures performance on student retention. No, that’s another rant altogether.
Two unique elements of these professions unite them. For one, they require a little more compassion to be effective than accounting or engineering and for another, they are traditionally (and still today mostly) filled by women. That both professions require years of training and are currently in dire need of willing employees suggests that the ladies have finally gotten wise and/or taken the advice of those who said “if you don’t like it, get the hell out.” Those who stay to stem the tide of disease and ignorance, must bear the derision of those who think they are stupid for staying in jobs that pay so little. Neither of these profession’s charges are generally kind. Patients who are sick or in pain are not always the most genial people. Students or parents who are convinced that their failure must be the fault of a flawed system frequently take out their frustration on the teacher as the most immediate representative. The irony is two-fold. That person is still in his or her profession because “helping people” is crucial to his or her ethos. The nurse or teacher must not only field regular abuse from patients, children and parents, but then must explain themselves to friends and family who suggest that they “do better.”
When did grace become the quality of the sucker?
I suggest that those in professions requiring compassion continue to leave their jobs for less vexing and better paying work. Nurses, teachers, social workers, service personnel, administrative assistants, etc. need to remember that this is the free market of a capitalist system, after all, and the only way to improve conditions is to continue to resist substandard pay and treatment. If our own compassion is used against us, it’s time to get with the tough-love, to refuse victimization and to speak with our feet. To all the hurt, helpless, homeless, hopeless and horror-struck, I’m sorry. Sometimes there’s no saving grace.